CAKE OR PIE?

Discussion in 'January And Everything After' started by RyanMM, Apr 9, 2012.

?

CAKE OR PIE?

Pie 59 vote(s) 58.4%
Cake 34 vote(s) 33.7%
I am a tasteless heathen 8 vote(s) 7.9%
  1. Bahimiron Already Beat BF's New Expansion

    EVERYTHING IS PIE!

    DO YOU LIKE FRENCH FRIES?!

    MORE LIKE FRENCH PIES!

    CHEESEBURGERS? PIES!

    STEAKS? PIES!

    VEGETARIAN CHILI? PIE!

    KAENG PHET PET YANG?! PIE! PIE! PIE! PIE!

    PIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  2. MrsWidget Keeper of the Elemental Materials

    God damn it, I bought a pie on the way home. Damn this thread.
    Lhowon, Bladida, balut and 5 others like this.
  3. MrsWidget Keeper of the Elemental Materials

    Recipe please!
  4. Rot Already Beat BF's New Expansion

    Location:
    Here
    I got the recipe here.
    It's also a great recipe if you're vegan and/or can't eat dairy.
    Bladida likes this.
  5. XPav Elitist Negative Nancy

    Location:
    Grogaboo hunting
    We are all made of pie stuff.
  6. Dean Despondent Fancybear

    Location:
    Cthulhu territory
    What's a brulee?

    Is there any kind of brulee other than creme?
  7. shift6 Magister Mundi Elyscape

    I had some key lime pancakes at a mom-and-pop breakfast joint last weekend. De-lish.
  8. Elyscape Already Beat BF's New Expansion

    Location:
    San Jose, CA
    "brûlée" means burned.
  9. RyanMM Magister Mundi Elyscape

    Location:
    Ferndale, MI
    A brulee is just custard that's had sugar poured on top and carmelized with a blowtorch. If you put it on top of a pie crust, you'd have creme brulee pie though.
    balut, Jacquelle and Elyscape like this.
  10. Dean Despondent Fancybear

    Location:
    Cthulhu territory
    I'd like a key lime brulee, please.
  11. RyanMM Magister Mundi Elyscape

    Location:
    Ferndale, MI
    I had a pina colada brulee once. That was awesome.
    I had a lavender brulee with fresh wild blueberries in it. That was sex.
    Elyscape likes this.
  12. Elyscape Already Beat BF's New Expansion

    Location:
    San Jose, CA
    There's a porno floating out there where the guy shows up just as the girl takes a cake out of the oven. He starts doing stuff with the girl but gets distracted by the cake, saying, "That cake looks good".

    Then he fucks the cake.
  13. RyanMM Magister Mundi Elyscape

    Location:
    Ferndale, MI
    Well, I'm not saying I didn't have fun with the bruelee before eating it.
  14. Muffin Already Beat BF's New Expansion

    Location:
    Austin, TX
    Was it pound cake?

    I'll show myself out.
    shift6, MulMizu, Sedrine and 8 others like this.
  15. Aeon221 Despondent Fancybear

    Location:
    G:\HAW HAW HAW
    You know what kind of pie is best?

    No pie.

    [IMG]
  16. MrPants Hard Cider Gal

    Let's not get carried away here. It's okay to like cake more than pie, but not liking pie at all is scientifically retarded.
    Umazes, Jacquelle, Ben Sones and 3 others like this.
  17. jeffd Armchair Designer

    Location:
    Oakhurst, NJ
    For what its worth, the cake and pie absolutists are ridiculous. If you're someone who is all pie uber alles cake sucks, that indicates that you haven't been exposed to anything other than, like, birthday cake.

    Just this past Thanksgiving I made a pumpkin roulade, which is a super-moist rolled cake with a vanilla cream-cheese filling. It was heavenly, and much better than pumpkin pie. That's not to say there's no room for pie: I like lots of pies! But taking an absolutist stance is, IMO, rather ridiculous.
    Umazes, Jacquelle, Hanacker and 3 others like this.
  18. MrPants Hard Cider Gal

    My mom used to make those and they're one of my favorite things on Earth.
  19. OZ 4.0 Despondent Fancybear

    Location:
    NJ
    I don't get this cream-cheese filling or frosting thing. Why would you ruin sweet, delicious cake by letting cheese anywhere within shouting distance of it?
  20. balut Magister Mundi Elyscape

    You're a bad person.
    MulMizu, MuffinMan, Soli-chan and 7 others like this.
  21. RyanMM Magister Mundi Elyscape

    Location:
    Ferndale, MI
    and he should feel bad.
    MulMizu, Soli-chan, Umazes and 3 others like this.
  22. Hanacker Armchair Designer

    Can we all at least agree that the standard pumpkin pie (store-bought and/or with canned filling) is pretty much at the bottom of the dessert hierarchy? I'm sure there are fantastic pumpkin pies out there, but by and large it seems like the only reason we ate them is because of tradition.
    RyanMM likes this.
  23. balut Magister Mundi Elyscape

    You, too, should feel bad.
    Umazes, Athryn and Bahimiron like this.
  24. OZ 4.0 Despondent Fancybear

    Location:
    NJ
    You want to hear my theory on cheese? Of course you do. I believe that everyone -- everyone -- who likes cheese can't taste it. If they could taste it, they would agree with me that in all of its forms, it is vile.
  25. MrsWidget Keeper of the Elemental Materials

    I like almost any kind of pumpkin pie :(
    Soli-chan, balut, Elyscape and 2 others like this.
  26. SwitchKnitter Already Beat BF's New Expansion

    Location:
    Central Florida
    So THAT'S the thing my mother in law has in the fridge! I wondered...
    Soli-chan likes this.
  27. Naterstein Hivemind Coordinator

    I voted pie because cheesecake and pecan pie are my favorite deserts in those two categories.
    balut, Umazes, Elyscape and 1 other person like this.
  28. Hanacker Armchair Designer

    You should probably stop posting in this thread already.
    Soli-chan, balut, Elyscape and 3 others like this.
  29. Ben Sones Elitist Negative Nancy

    Location:
    Lordran
    I love cheese. I mean, in all seriousness, I could live on nothing but cheese and be fairly happy. But! I don't care for cheesecake because the texture seems super-weird to me. And plain cheesecake has this sort of bland, cloying richness that I don't really like, though flavored cheesecakes can be okay.

    The cream cheese frosting is also the downfall of red velvet cake, IMHO. The cake is great, but that frosting just has an unpleasant mouth-feel.
    Elyscape likes this.
  30. OZ 4.0 Despondent Fancybear

    Location:
    NJ
    But I must stand strong with the forces of non-cheesy cake!

    But not carrot cake. What kind of warped individual thought "cake is awesome, but you know what? It would be better with vegetables in it." I mean, really.
  31. MrPants Hard Cider Gal

    An awesome individual, that's who.
    balut, Elyscape and Jacquelle like this.
  32. Athryn Despondent Fancybear

    I am somewhat traumatized by carrot cake, as that was the super trendy thing to make wedding cakes out of in the '70s, when all my moms friends got married. I ate far too much of it, so I am not much of a fan.
  33. Elyscape Already Beat BF's New Expansion

    Location:
    San Jose, CA
    Until the scurvy kicked in.
    Sedrine and Umazes like this.
  34. U.S. Millie Elitist Negative Nancy

    FFS Ely, you can get cheese with fruit in it. :|
  35. RyanMM Magister Mundi Elyscape

    Location:
    Ferndale, MI
    Actually, you're talking to someone who hates cheese.

    The only exceptions to that rule are cream cheese in desserts when augmented with sugar, and flavorless mozzarella on a pizza that's doused in flavorful sauce and toppings.

    The mere thought of the smell of cheddar makes me nauseous.
  36. Kalle Despondent Fancybear

    Location:
    Sweden
    Imagine someone who hates beer. That's how I feel about you right now. Someone denied the simple pleasure of something tasty and delicious.
  37. Lhowon Hard Cider Gal

    I know right? You think you know a guy.
    Jacquelle, Soli-chan and Elyscape like this.
  38. Muffin Already Beat BF's New Expansion

    Location:
    Austin, TX
    Thinking about blocking RyanMM right now.
  39. Umazes Hatoful Pigeon

    Location:
    Canada
    Though I agree that cheese doesn't have the best smell, it's fucking delicious and anybody who says otherwise is a bad person.
  40. MulMizu Sassy Black Woman

    So uh.
    Today, I treated myself to a little bit of this.

    [IMG]

    My body is still quivering.
    Saxman_72, Bladida, Dean and 5 others like this.