[MOD CLARIFICATION PLEASE] Final thing before I hit bed. If John is the monster then he can't Judge. What happens in the case of a tie then? If it is a no lynch we can use this to test if John has been taken. This will also allow us one more day to Lynch. Depending on what the MOD says about the above; If we vote 2 for John and two for someone else (me I guess), if John can judge then he can choose the someone else, and if he cannot then we get a no lynch. One of us die tonight, then the others can lynch John. Ideally, considering my options above about who it could be I would say John and Aaron but I don't think this is a goer, so choose me. If John is safe, you take me out (and we lose I guess, but it protects you from the possibility of me being a monster) and if John is a monster then we get a No Lynch and you can lynch him tomorrow. Obviously, if Aaron is an artful liar then we are still dead.